The Morning After

There was a lot of talk among Democrats and their fellow travelers before the general election about the crisis in the GOP. Donald Trump – outlandish, buffoonish and downright unelectable – had, by winning the party’s nomination, led the Republican Party to drink from the waters that it had so terribly polluted.  He had taken the party’s possibly cynical embrace of rightwing crazies like Tea Partiers, creationists and anti-choicers to its logical conclusion: implosion.

 But who’s in crisis now? Whose party is in danger of, if not implosion, then sliding into a period of weak and floundering opposition to the know-nothing GOP juggernaut that is now firmly in control of things?

If the Democrats can’t even defeat a candidate like Donald Trump, can they ever be expected to retake the White House or regain a majority in either or both houses of Congress? Will our citizens ever be freed from the tyranny of state governments run by ignorant Republicans hell bent on destroying all that is public and not profitable?

We’re at the long receiving end of the so-called Reagan “revolution,” my friends, a decades-long realignment of political forces and economic priorities. It’s been a long time since Democrats could count on unorganized white workers to vote for them – maybe because it’s been a long time since the Democrats have done anything for anybody because they’re workers.  Black, Latino, and women workers benefit from civil rights policies, which the Democrats are still willing to support, so they still support Democrats but not as workers.

As for organized workers, it’s long past time for labor to stop busting their asses for the Democrats who only repay them with support for economic policies that must have folks like John L. Lewis, Phil Murray and even FDR spinning in their graves.

Occupy the political space

For the past decade or so, liberal Dems have staked their fortunes and future on demographic changes that their naïve, if well meaning, policy wonks have termed “cultural.” Culture is somehow interwoven with “identity,” and everybody has to be identified.  She’s not just a woman; she’s an Afro-Asian with a hint of Scotch-Irish woman!  Once everyone is correctly identified, we can come up with the algorithm for optimum “diversity.”

The word diversity is now spoken as if there’s some magic in its very utterance. It might come as a surprise to some people to learn that this has always been a diverse country, made up of people of many different races, from many different places, who have had many different experiences. And here’s a tidbit about “minorities:” people who have been excluded aren’t concerned about diversity – they want inclusion and fairness.  Inclusion might refer to the right to a decent education, good-paying job and a nice house or apartment to live in.  An example of fairness would be not being shot by police under circumstances that white citizens would survive.

The Occupy movement was on the right track when it said that there are those making money, and then there are the rest of us. The ninety-nine percent includes people of all races, genders, nationalities, religions and ages.  Once upon a time, they were called members of the working class and the middle class.  We don’t use that working-class term much anymore, except to disparage (some of) the people who voted for Donald Trump.  I suggest we start using that word again to describe the people who, well . . . work.  Then we might want to rethink what it really means to be in the middle.

On this “morning after” an election where we learned just how cuckoo our political system has become, I suggest we save some of our vitriol for Trump voters and give it to the Democrats who haven’t really been for the working people for a very long time. It’s time to stop supporting smooth, cynical, venal politicians who don’t give a rat’s ass about common people once the election season is over.

I wrote earlier that the ruling class – even elites in the Republican Party – had lined up behind Hillary Clinton, and so they had. But now the GOP controls the entire federal government and the majority of state governments as well, and you can bet that that’s just fine with this same ruling class.  Their interests will be well served by a billionaire landlord who believes in lowering taxes on corporations and the rich, while lowering the boom on the rest of us.

And so I suggest, once again, in the words of the immortal Joe Hill: Don’t waste time mourning; organize! Let’s make the next four years very uncomfortable for Trump and the GOP.

— James Collins

Gridiron Grit

NFL quarterback Colin Kaepernick has restored the role of the black athlete as a leading fighter for human rights in general, and specifically for the rights of African Americans.  His simple act of kneeling, rather than standing with hand on heart, during the playing of the Star Spangled Banner has inspired myriad acts of protest and solidarity from athletes at all levels, ranging from pre-teen youth to professional football and basketball players.

The practice of not worshipping the flag and related trappings of patriotism at sporting events has impacted the Pittsburgh area in a big way.  People are taking a stand for equality by taking the knee, and some of the heroes aren’t even athletes – they’re player supporters like parents, fans and cheerleaders.

The fans and cheerleaders of Cornell High School in Coraopolis haven’t had much to cheer about on the gridiron — the Raiders have yet to win a game – but on September 30th twelve out of fifteen Cornell cheerleaders took a knee during the playing of the national anthem.  The honor guard at that particular game happened to represent the local VFW post, and so the protest prompted tears, vitriol and stupid statements like “these kids don’t know what they’re doing.”

Don’t know what they’re doing? How about, protesting racism?

More ominously, Superintendent Aaron Thomas, his family and other administrators received hundreds of threatening phone calls as the Youtube video went viral and paragons of truth and reason like the website Blue Lives Matter spread the lie that Thomas had deliberately set the vets up.  To Thomas and the school board’s credit, the rights of the students to protest were respected, but because of the threats, attendance at the homecoming game two weeks later was restricted to parents of players.

The bold action of the cheerleaders, with the parents standing behind them, and the superintendent standing behind them, is representative of the pluck of this small community. The very existence of this year’s winless football team is a victory: it is the first team Cornell has fielded in five years.  The last team, from 2011, went 5-5 and made the WPIAL playoffs.  This year’s team has few players with any high school football experience – just a few who had suited up for Quaker Valley in previous seasons but none of them had gotten any playing time.

Cornell serves residents of Coraopolis and Neville Township, small working-class communities whose population has dwindled over the decades – Coraopolis has about 5,600 residents and Neville about 1,000 – so there aren’t a lot of kids in the district.  The percentage of African-Americans, in both Coraopolis and the school district, is rising.

The response of Thomas, the school board, coaching staff and parents is commendable. Rather than give in to those who would mischaracterize legitimate (and respectful) protest speech as something else, this small working-class community seems to be holding the line and supporting their youth.

Abide no evil

Last month, three players from Woodland Hills took a knee during the national anthem during a game at Bethel Park.  The all-black team was then subjected to racial taunts from the stands and from opposing players.  This was a game in the Parkway Youth Football League, whose players are 12-and-under.

The same three Wolverines had taken a knee earlier in the season, with no backlash from fans. When questioned then by their coach about the motive of their actions, they reasonably enough felt strongly about the spate of cop-on-black killings – especially the shooting of young Tamir Rice in Cleveland.  Coach Marcus Burkley Sr. decided to support their right to express their opinions.  He was proud of how his team kept its composure in Bethel Park, going on to win the game by a score of 20-6.  (See the Oct. 15 Post-Gazette.)

The president of the Bethel Park team promised an investigation and Woodland Hills officials were initially optimistic.  But it turned out to be a hear-no-evil investigation.  The Bethel Park Junior Football Board released a statement that said, “Not one individual we spoke with observed, witnessed or can corroborate Woodland Hills’ accusations of racial slurs or discrimination.”

But Woodland Hills supporters aren’t buying it and in a massive show of solidarity, dozens of fans of all ages – black and white – took a knee before the young Wolverines’ home game against Moon Township late last month.

A lot of divisive trash talk has congealed around the election and the response to the police shootings of people of color, attempting to portray our reality as black against white, native born versus immigrants, and scary blacks versus hard-pressed cops. But these local incidents point the way forward. White people can and do support the sanctity of black lives and our right to protest injustice.  In both cases, these are working-class communities where black and white live in close proximity to one another and go to school together.

And it is the young people who have forced the issue; thank goodness the adults responded.


— Jim Collins